Vote for Nature 2022 - Dunedin City Council

Aaron Hawkins (Green Ōtepoti)

Running for Mayor

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Climate change.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Climate action is the big one, and that includes through committing to the Predator Free vision. Possums are bad for carbon sinks.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6.

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Prioritise action that supports the Zero Carbon goal, and continue to invest in the South Dunedin Future programme as an example of community-led climate adaptation.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

There is no sustainable and equitable future for Dunedin without a shift away from our reliance on fossil fuels (and private motor vehicles full stop).

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Continue to push for a higher quality, and more affordable, bus service. Support predator control and urban biodiversity programmes. Invest in our Zero Waste goals.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

I support the objectives (better health and environmental outcomes; a stronger role for Māori in the system), but am not convinced the proposed model is the best option for delivering them. Still too many questions around things like town planning, civil defence operations, and pricing to give a more exact opinion.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6.

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

It’s a difficult question, given how we’re anticipating control of (and decisions around) stormwater sitting with another entity. We definitely need to make more of an effort to control the impact of urban activity on the natural environment.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5.

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Continue to prioritise transport projects that support public and active transport (Princes St Bus Priority, Park & Ride etc), and advocate for greater investment in service improvements and affordability.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes.

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

I support a shift from the status quo, which is inevitable, and welcome the process early next year to discuss the options designed to support that shift.

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes.

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6.

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Continue to support the City Sanctuary project, and the wider Predator Free Dunedin effort.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes.

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

I am always open to options that support our goals, including biodiversity outcomes, where they are within our powers or have an advocacy approach we can get behind.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes.

Brent Weatherall (Team Dunedin)

Running for Dunedin City Council

Bruce Mitchell

Running for Dunedin City Council

Carmen Houlahan (Independent)

Running for Mayor and Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Climate change

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Work towards the goal to reach carbon zero by 2030 

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

I think we have the right idea but we have had a lot of talking but not enough action, in my opinion. For example, we do not have a plan. If you want to achieve anything you need a plan. And we need to have realistic goals and know how we are going to achieve them. We need to work with large industries and businesses to achieve this

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

We need to improve public transport. I would like to see buses free for students and unemployed and more frequent. A daily passenger rail service from Mosgiel to Dunedin. (central Government would need to fund this) Also, an express bus or train from the airport to the city. An electric loop bus that goes from the exchange to the University, stopping and starting to let people on and off. A bit like the trams in Melbourne. It could connect up with a park and ride transport hub in St Andrew Street. This hub would provide carparking, charging stations for electric cars, secure parking for electric bikes and scooters.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Work with Council staff to get a plan written. Engage with businesses and large organisations to agree to the 2030 target.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No not in its current form. I have many concerns about it. The potential loss of local voice, local knowledge, so many questions still not answered. For example, will it mean water metering and how will that work? How will the shares work for assets? Government says under the 3 waters entity bill that if Councils pass a motion that the Government deems detrimental to 3 waters it can revoke the decision. This is anti democratic for the Government to threaten to revoke decisions by democratically elected councillors. Under the Bill the government can take council staff to start work on the new entity. This leaves Councils vulnerable as it is difficult to get experienced three waters staff. Dunedin is part of entity D which includes the whole of the South Island. There would be 22 councils in this entity but only six places on the governance table for councils. It is very likely Dunedin would not even get a seat at the table under these odds. Mana whenua would also have six positions on the governance table. Our Council’s preferred option, if we have to go ahead with 3 Waters, is to be part of a Otago Southland model.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

invest in new infrastructure where needed. We are currently doing this and our water systems are getting upgraded around the city. We have a lot of money in our current 10 year plan towards 3 waters. I would continue to do this. Also I would actively work to secure and maintain good staff in these areas who have extensive knowledge. Work with manawhenua, and community groups. Communicate strong messages to the public about the importance of keeping our water ways clean. Work with planning not to over intensify the land. Maintain arable land in Dunedin for sustainability of food sources.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Start open and honest discussions with ORC. Make a plan to improve problem areas. Advocate for more funding from Government to subsidise or fully fund bus fares. Also refer to my action plans for transport above.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Only if we can guarantee we can do a better job and only if we have agreement from ORC. I do not think the answer is taking over the buses. I think the first step is good communication, honest discussions to solve the problems.

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No this is crazy. It will congest our whole city. If there are major traffic jams cars idling create more emissions which goes against our carbon zero plan

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

No I support having bollards that could be put up to close off sections of the street for events but I do not support it becoming one way. George Street is a thoroughfare for traffic and making it one way will congest our city. We need much better public transport to help solve some of these problems. I do not think pedestrianising the city is the answer.

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

4

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Support more organisations like the Orokinui Sanctuary.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

if there was money available

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

I would not like to get rid of people’s pets but I would be happy to discuss ways to control cat numbers and movements.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

I am not a supporter of 1080 so if it was up to me no but I would be happy to look for more natural alternatives. 1080 has been banned in many other places around the world. I think it is about time we looked for better alternatives that are not so toxic.

Cheryl May Neill (Team Dunedin)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Diesel buses, flooding, harbour pollution.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Continue the support of biodiversity groups in Dunedin. Dogs are only allowed onto certain areas on beaches. Active programmes to explore harbour pollution solutions.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Remove diesel buses, and replace them with smaller electric buses. Park, and ride share for people out in the suburbs to have easy access to buses.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

Introduction of electric buses, buses which charge overnight, eventually light rail. This would result in less congestion and fewer fossil fuels. Extra funding from Central Govt with careful business case studies to ascertain financial viability. Free parking at off-peak times for electric, hybrid cars. I would continue to walk as much as I can especially walking to work as I do most days.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Continue the good work various community groups are doing with riparian planting, and replanting forests to offset carbon emissions. Provide incentives for people to use buses or ride-share in cars. Use of low carbon fuel-efficient vehicles.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No. Four large entities in charge of the whole country are too many. Many of the councils throughout the country already have efficient systems in place. There has not been enough consultation taken place to find other alternatives. Dunedin has the people and the resources to manage their own water. One idea that has been mooted is to have smaller areas such as Otago-Southland which would be more manageable.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

All the good work that is being done in South Dunedin needs to be continued. The council must redivert wastewater pipes from Kaikorai to Green Island so it is not going through Caversham. Central Govt must be involved in assisting in cost management.

Climate change and natural hazards risks must be managed well. Explore what other countries are doing to combat this. Introduce groundwater monitoring stations in South Dunedin.

Create more green spaces such as using parts of Forbury Park as a wetland to absorb heavy rain. Forbury Park, Kettle Park and Tonga Park could also be a temporary holding place for water. I would support the Halo Project and continue with the ongoing monitoring of waterways.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Make the bus service more attractive to students by introducing an annual bus pass payable when payable university fees; eg $100 per year. Increase the frequency of buses, widen route networks, review bus timetables, and pay better wages to bus drivers. Free loop service around the CBD. Regular bus routes through Princes and George Street every 15 minutes. Park n Ride facility at Green Island or Sunnyvale, St Clair. Bus service to go all the way to Taiaroa Heads.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

8

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

I think the predator control efforts are currently being very well managed. Through the work of Predator Free Dunedin, Halo Project and other groups are already doing a great job in reducing predators.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes. The feral cat problem is increasing all the time. Microchipping may be a good idea.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes, sometimes there are no other options available.

Chris McBride (Independent)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Rubbish and waste ending up in our environment. Take a walk down any of our roads or highways and see what is lying in the gutters, storm drains and nearby green spaces. This should not be an issue if we all took pride in our community.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

I want to see the eradication of gorse on farmland, it is out of control. Unproductive land should be planted out in natives. I would strengthen littering policies and actively promote this and support waterway rejuvenation projects.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

4

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Build resilience within the community and infrastructure. Support a move to true low carbon energies such as hydrogen and encourage more users into public transport. But do not penalise car use.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

Limited - Hybrid, Electric and Hydrogen technology is the future of personal transport. These technologies are fast becoming the norm in our lives. The council should enable our infrastructure to accommodate these fuel sources.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Support infrastructure for low emission modes of transport. I would have a strong focus on establishing a true recycling facility. We must have a reduce, reuse, recycle mindset. We need to enhance greenspaces in our urban environment.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No, I believe centralisation of local services does not provide the best outcome. We will lose our local voice and if government has an issue with underperforming localities then work with that authority, do not punish everyone.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Work with business, landowners and community to target problematic locations and find suitable solutions. Plant species which combat toxins in our waterways. Continue to improve our water infrastructure and monitor closely.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

I would advocate for free bus travel for all, I would like to see the bus service move to an on-demand service for low volume and evening services. We could reduce the size of buses and focus services on where the demand is.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Support projects such as Predator Free Dunedin and the Halo project, look to increase scopes of such ventures. Create a bounty system for pests and predators which will incentivise community to get involved.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes

Chriss Hamilton

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

The current and future impacts of Climate Change. Undoubtably. Waste management is another top priority because of its impacts on our local environment.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

As a Councillor, I would be looking for and supporting an environmental response in every DCC policy. Policies inform operational change, and these should, therefore, support practices responsive to the impacts of climate change. All policies should acknowledge their effect on the environment and on waste minimisation. Robust policies which proactively consider these factors should also align with local and central government strategies. In fact, Dunedin City’s strategy, policies and practices should align with the UNSDGs and proactively contribute to achieving these aims.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

The DCC is already committed to the Zero Carbon 2030 strategy, which focuses on the reduction of emissions. Additionally, the Emissions Management and Reduction Plan sets specific targets, states who is accountable, and details specific operational actions within the DCC’s control to meet those targets. This is a good start. But there is much more work to do because climate change is not just about emissions. For example, the city needs to be protected from future weather extremes, e.g. flooding, land slips, etc… The availability of clean drinking water must also be maintained in the face of drought or contamination, as much for residents, as for our local flora and fauna. Energy production should be reliable and local, wherever practicable. Waste management and minimisation is a huge area of concern for ratepayers. Changes are already underway, but I think there are also business opportunities for the city to play in part in NZ’s recycling future, i.e. to reduce NZ’s need to export waste. Each of these challenges can be tackled by adopting a simple, principled, problem-solving process. Ratepayers need Councillors who will heed the science and expertise, and who are willing to work together to solve problems, instead of pushing political agendas. Furthermore, the DCC overall, cannot act in isolation and should routinely and proactively partner with business and the wider community to find innovative solutions. Education is a key component of changing our response to the impacts of climate change because everyone has a part to play and at times this can be overwhelming for individuals and individual businesses. We need to normalise the changes expected of individuals and education is the key to doing that. It is by working together, I believe we’ll have a greater chance of meeting our environmental targets.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

My long-term vision for Dunedin City is one that demonstrates achievement towards each of the 17 United Nations Sustainability Development Goals. In fact, I would like to see Dunedin lead New Zealand in its achievement of these goals. Developing a quality system of public transportation is key to ensuring Dunedin is an inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable city. It directly contributes to our economic growth, when we are less reliant on the oil industry, and we all know that clean, affordable energy is good for the planet. We should certainly pedestrianize more of the central city and encourage a move towards more shared transport. However, I also believe this can be done without limiting the access of emergency vehicles or exorbitant spending of roading changes. A degree of flexibility should be maintained to ensure we have a sustainable and viable city to face whatever challenges may arise in the future.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

As discussed above, I would advocate for all policies and Council decision-making to demonstrate a response to climate change and waste minimisation. I would advocate for a formal partnership and a joint problem-solving approach to be adopted for tackling environmental matters. I would invest in education, so that the complex science behind climate change impacts and waste management was more easily understood by businesses, community groups and individuals. This could be done by drawing together a group of local experts willing to provide advice and answer questions, to inform quality decision-making. Education is the key to ensuring everyone is capable and motivated to playing their part in combating the impacts of climate change.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

Yes. This is long overdue. For decades now, too many Councils have deferred essential maintenance and are now facing enormous infrastructure costs which simply cannot be met without the input of central government funding. It’s important to me that the public should now and in the future retain ownership of NZ’s water infrastructure and I will always advocate for this. We should expect consistency with regard to water quality, drainage, and sewerage across the country, not just for our good, but for the good of NZ’s flora and fauna. We live in one country. Therefore, the impacts of climate change and waste management impact us as a country, not solely as a region and not solely as a city. We must work together, in the best interests of the country, to overcome the challenges of climate change. The DCC and ORC simply cannot operate water management in isolation because our environments are linked, well beyond any authority’s boundary line.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

One of the UNSDGs relates specifically to the security and quality of clean water. This is something best managed by the country in unison, with plenty of local input, because our freshwater supplies are interlinked and connected. Local authorities must work together, in partnership, to ensure adequacy and quality of drinking water. The 3 Waters approach supports and enables local authorities to do that. However, 3 Waters management has yet to be finally determined and there are still some details to be worked out. I would take a problem-solving, partnership approach to working out those areas of disagreement. Let’s find the common ground, be well-informed to discuss solutions, find the best option, and implement it. To defend the quality of our freshwater, we must address the impacts of intensive agriculture. I would work with the ORC and local agriculturists, to help find solutions to the problems. Its in all our best interests to improve the quality of our freshwater infrastructure, so we need to work together to make that improvement. Thankfully, we have plenty of local expertise to draw upon to inform that conversation. I would also review relevant DCC strategy and policy to ensure that practice is as robust as possible. Where necessary, some by-laws may need to be strengthened. I suggest a joint project with the ORC to specifically consider what changes both authorities could agree on and jointly enforce. A united front would certainly send a clear message to those needing to make change. But we should also work together to lend support, where needed, to make those changes a success.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

I would proactively work with the key players to implement a much-improved system of public transportation. First, we all need to agree on the outcomes expected of that system. My goal is to develop public transportation which is, efficient, sustainable, viable, that meets business and ratepayer needs. It needs to be cheaper, faster, more regular, reliable, and timely. We also need a new, free-to-all, CBD bus loop. I envisage smaller buses ferrying shoppers, students and workers in and out of the CBD quickly, (every ten minutes), and linking to suburban bus routes north, south, east and west. This service is desperately needed to revitalise our business and retail hub – we need to make it easier for people to get in and out of town throughout the day. I’d also make sure this service was running for city events in the evening. We need smaller, faster, more efficient, reliable, and regular buses. I’m tired of seeing empty buses and, like many ratepayers, I’m tired of big buses clogging intersections or using two lanes to turn a corner without driving over a chicane. It shouldn’t take me 40 minutes to get to work on the bus when it takes me 10 minutes by car. Public transportation is a top priority because without a quality service in place, many of the other changes introduced by Council to address climate change, the hospital rebuild and road safety become a nonsense without a well-established, sustainable and efficient system of public transport.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

I note there is currently no DCC pest control policy, but the DCC does have pest control practices for possums, rodents, rabbits, goats, pigs, wasps and mustelids. A new policy linking pest control activities to strategic aims to practice should be informed by quality, academic research. We have expertise on our doorstep in Dunedin, so let’s include it in our decision-making.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

By-laws and other controls must be easily implemented, and enforceable. There is a cost to ratepayers for ensuring compliance, and I would want to see that cost/benefit analysis before making decisions. With regard to cat controls, I’d be concerned that those who ignore good practice, won’t suddenly adopt good practice in the future even if it becomes a by-law. Again, by-laws need to be enforceable and I’m not yet clear on how a cat-identification by-law would be enforceable, in a cost-effective manner, other than by imposing a fine. With regard to microchipping cats, the problem this solves is identifying the cat’s owner, when the cat is caught in a trap or found dead. But there are other options to identify cats, e.g. a collar and medallion. The choice for how to identify a cat should be the owners’, because they incur the cost. But certainly, ownership identification should be strongly encouraged. I support the work of the RSPCA and Cat Rescue, which both do an amazing job of desexing cats and finding suitable homes for these animals. Both also spend time educating people about good cat care and proactively include microchipping in their work.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

I think we should use a variety of methods for pest control. 1080 is simply one option. If it is to be used, it needs to be used in a way that doesn’t create greater risks to flora and fauna, than the pests themselves. 1080 is cost-effective given New Zealand’s rugged terrain and inaccessible areas. However, I remain open to alternatives, should the science support them.

Christine Garey (Independent)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

The impact of climate change as an ongoing threat to the rich biodiversity of Ōtepoti. We need to strengthen and protect our local ecosystems in the face of climate change.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Continue supporting DCC initiatives/projects that protect and restore Dunedin’s wildlife & environment: Biodiversity Grants for landowners/volunteers planting projects/predator control & support for the Wildlife Hosptial.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

With urgency! Resource/support work which puts the climate crisis response as a top priority including: work towards the City’s carbon zero goal 2030; waste minimisation & improved public transport, & South Dunedin Futures programme.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

We need a future-ready city: communities where people have warm, dry homes and transport options, not reliant on fossil fuels. A city where our taonga species and natural environment thrive and business is underpinned by sustainability.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Continue to resource, support and champion the critical work of DCC’s Zero Carbon team and based on evidence, vote in support at every opportunity; and through meaningful debate, persuade colleagues to do the same!

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

I support Council’s submissions opposing aspects of the proposal, including Entity D which is so large, it will dilute local voice. However, the new water standards, already in place, have wide support as it hard to disagree with access to safe drinking water.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Continue to invest in three waters infrastructure. In particular, I want to see the priority list for the public /private stormwater projects worked through at pace, to address all of those issues before we lose influence.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

A reliable, accessible, affordable public transport system is key to zero carbon goals, no matter who runs it! A centre city bus loop, as proposed by Clr Benson-Pope & measures to make public transport the preferred option, I will support.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

Yes

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

8

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Continue to champion the work of the Predator Free groups and vote at Council to resource their work. If a member of the Grants Subcommittee next triennium, which I have chaired in this term, support their work through this avenue.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes, the time is right. As referenced recently, there is stakeholder support for cat control measures across the community. Last time it was raised in local government circles, it did not attract that level of support.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

While recognising this is a controversial solution to an important issue, I believe that transparent and strategic use of 1080 continues to be a valuable tool within essential conservation work.

David Benson-Pope (Independent)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Infrastructural works on waste and storm water (especially improved storm water management), and Improved public transport.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Any and all that contribute to the cause. Residents know my track-record of support for environmental and biodiversity improvement projects in Dunedin and surrounds. Long-time supporter of Save the Otago Peninsula (STOP) and the Yellow-eyed Penguin Trust along with other associated groups. Immediate past chair of Te Ao Turoa. Minister for the Environment in the Clark government.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

By ensuring the implementation of the already agreed ambitions goals.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

Comprehensive public transport available, ideally free, in a fully electric bus fleet. Including in the short term an inner-city low or no-emission bus loop. Continued urban-design improvements to make our inner city streets more attractive and user-friendly for all users. Comprehensive way-finding guidance for drivers to assist them in finding the available car-parking (which expert advice tells us is plentiful).

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

As demonstrated to date by my voting record, and as necessary to achieve agreed goals.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No, I consider it ill conceived, poorly managed and most likely undeliverable. I do however support the stated intent of ensuring potable water for smaller communities, who don’t have the ability or political will to do that for themselves.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

10

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Expect that we continue to provide safe drinking-water city-wide.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

Wanting.

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

DCC policy is that the city should control our public transport. I support that view.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

Yes. Because the advice including the Health Impact assessment of change recommends that.

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes. Let’s enjoy the hard-won new urban environment! Looking forward to it.

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

8

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

I think all the work has been great. Especially supportive of the Halo Project and the Predator Free initiatives in general. Big ups to all those involved. )PS My Timms trap has helped to discourage to local varmints

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes. I can’t see how we can deal to the feral cat issue otherwise.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes

Jett Groshinski (Independent)

Running for Mayor and Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

The most pressing issue that is facing Dunedin is climate change and we need immediate action.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Create a system for proper monitoring and evaluation of our strategies. We must also create a climate action plan so that we can actually deliver on climate change.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Dunedin needs action throughout the entire city, increasing the public transport service and prioritising a climate action plan. We must also continue the work the council is doing in South Dunedin.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

There are always people that are going to use cars but moving it to a more sustainable electric vehicle based and public transport focused. We need to get people out of private motor vehicles that can.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Create a Climate action plan and commit to action, prioritise the 2030 zero carbon emissions goal and push for a better public transport system.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No, I believe in safe, reliable drinking water, wastewater, and stormwater. However, I do not believe anyone can support the way the government has gone about it.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

We need more of a commitment to improving freshwater however it is unclear with the three waters reforms what a council will be able to do.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Advocate for Dunedin City Council to take control of the public transport system.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Continue funding Predator Free and work more towards a partnership to see where the council can support it.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

I am open to discussion of what can be done however I am not fully aware of the current situation.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes, when other methods are not practicable but not when it is deemed the “most cost-effective method.”

Joy Davis (Labour)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Climate change.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Support continued growth in our partnership with man whenua, and others as we work to retain, protect and restore our natural environments and ecosystems. Support sustainable practices and forward planning across the range of DCC activities, with our goal to zero carbon emissions by 2030

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Continue to work on our understanding of its impact locally and plan accordingly. Communicate well with our residents, partner with local communities, ORC and central government to find and implement workable solutions

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

A vibrant safe city which is accessible to all. Accessible, affordable, low or zero emmisons public transport, is key to social connection and wellbeing. Establish an integrated transport system ( run by one council) which promotes and enhances safe pedestrian spaces and other transport modes, such as cycling. Fewer cars on the road, look into Park N Ride, car pooling and train options.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Strongly support the initiatives outlined above, take personal responsibility for further reducing my carbon footprint.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

The three waters initiative must happen, I don’t agree with some of the implementation detail and am pleased there are ongoing conversations to modify these. Dunedin City needs to continue to be a leader in this dialogue. The proposal has merit, but elements need to be reworked and our communities invited to participate, to be better informed.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

I would need to get up to speed on the facts of the current situation and proposals to address them before committing to a specific answer, but naturally would support all practical initiatives for improvement

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

I am keen to continue talks with ORC and Central Govt. An efficient, affordable, accessible, and environmentally friendly transport network is essential for residents’ social connection and wellbeing. One supporting different travel modes, pedestrian spaces and cycling options. I support a service which connects resident across the city, to our parks and recreational facilities, one that contributes to a safe and vibrant city Ongoing engagement between the ORC and DCC and government must continue. One council to be responsible for the entire transport service, determined by evidence presented.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

Yes

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

This is an area I need to learn more about before commenting

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Reluctantly yes

Jules Radich (Team Dunedin)

Running for Mayor and Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Lack of action on emissions.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Clean up the Kaikorai Stream. Properly publicise predator-free NZ.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

2

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Reduce emissions. Increase diversion from landfill, protect South Dunedin.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

Steady reduction of fossil fuel consumption with EV & PHEV prioritisation. Public transport usage dramatically increased with convenience & reliability. All PT electric.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

As above. Protect South Dunedin with erosion prevention, better pipes and an extra pumping station. Standing energy review and emission reduction.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No. Water is a catchment issue and should be conglomerated accordingly. This will retain local control and responsiveness. It is also more likely to achieve cost-effectiveness in my observation. I support Taumata Arowai and Te Mana o te Wai.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Our freshwater is actually rated pretty highly, coming as it does from our own catchment among distant hills at Deep Stream. Smaller urban areas need upgrades and an alternative large supply would provide greater resilience although we do have short-term backups.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Two sizes of bus instead of just 1. The other being a small electric 14-18 seater. All buses electric in 3-5 years. An ALL stakeholder working party to meet monthly. A major focus shift to usage rather than any other imperative. Usage to be increased with convenience and reliability.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

No

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes, but it should be 2-Way for PT

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Properly publicise the program to get more householders involved.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes

Lynette Scott (Team Dunedin)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

The most pressing issue is coastal erosion. If elected, I will be supporting the re-introduction of groynes at St. Clair beach. There needs to be a plan for South Dunedin to protect if from rising sea levels. Integral to this would be the purchase of Forbury Park by Council so it can be used to help moderate water levels in South Dunedin.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

I oppose the Smooth Hill landfill. We should be recycling more. I would also like to see investment in recycling technologies so we put less into our landfill. I believe there needs to be more control of cats in Dunedin to protect bidlife and I would like to see a registration system, similar to dogs.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

There have to be a broad range of actions to reduce carbon emissions. There has to be better public transport to encourage people to use it, but also we need better parking for those who still need to drive…currently a lot of emissions are caused by poor wayfinding for parking. I’d also like to see some grass berms replanted in fruit trees or flowers to reduce emissions from mowing and provide food for people and bees.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

The city should be aiding the transition to electric vehicles through provision of EV charging stations. Also better parking and wayfinding for parking so that there are fewer emissions from people driving around to find a park.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

If elected, I want to promote a public transport that uses renewable energy – both buses and also a commuter rail service to Mosgiel and Port Chalmers. I want there to be a plan for South Dunedin, it should be protecting the land and not resigning to retreat. I want action on coastal erosion – re-instating the groynes and I want to see some grassed public spaces planted in fruit trees and flowers.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No I don’t support it. The ratepayers of Dunedin have paid for the infrastructure in the city. It shouldn’t be given away. Keeping drinking, storm and waste water controlled locally will give the best outcome for the people of Dunedin.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Compared to many places, Dunedin has good quality water. I don’t think there needs to be change.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

There is too much congestion in the central city. We need to move to smaller electric buses. There also has to be a more reliable service – DCC and ORC have to work together to create a bus service that caters for the needs of the people, including school children. I also want to see the re-introduction of a commuter rail service to both Mosgiel and Port Chalmers which will reduce congestion on the roads. This service could use trains run on renewable energy.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

No

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

I would like to see the introduction of a cat register, similar to a dog register.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes. There should be a cat registration system, similar to dogs. The biggest problem is feral cats, not domesticated moggies. The feral cat population grows when cats are abandoned or breed without control. I’d like to advocate compulsory microchips and neutering of cats. People wanting to breed cats should need a licence to do so.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

No. 1080 is poison.

Mandy Mayhem Bullock

Running for Mayor and Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Climate Change Climate change adaptation act is currently tracking slowly. No certainty around the timeline which is of concern, this slowness, given that across the nation there are increased weather events on a regular basis. Increasing instability What can be done now to give councils and communities tools. I am an emergency response group coordinator for my area and I encourage readiness and resilience for all our communities (especially coastal or low lying)

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin? Native and Wetland Plantings, waterway protection, Fire protections for places of significance needing greater resilience and pest eradication. I support the current sand dune restoration projects, river care groups. Currently the chair of Keep Dunedin Beautiful our annual events include- Trees for families ( planting the harbour side cycleway ) Clean up week each September and other litter collection projects We organise Adopt a spot, student clean up days and litter audits, encouraging every one to recycle, and Be a Tidy kiwi ( our motto ) Portsmouth drive clean up post recent storm event was our initiative, working with the taskforce green team

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

I support the current carbon zero 2030 policy. Transport mode improvements will help. Addressing the Bus service is important. And a serious look at a commuter rail into the city. I think the new 4 bin rubbish system will reduce our land fill waste,I would like to see more education around Reduce, reuse, recycle. The city could do more to support keep cup initiatives. City Holdings could reduce plastic cup use at huge events like they host at the stadium.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

I support multi modal transport, active transport, free public bus loops, park and ride, commuter and passenger rail restoration, general future proofing for growth, equality and accessible city for all of its residents

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Waste reduction needs to be a priority, and lowering carbon emissions We need coastal plans and greater resilience for all of our low lying communities I work closely with Civil Defence Emergency Management and Fire and emergency New Zealand (sitting on Local advisory committee for Otago ) I support

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

I think it is a bigger more contentious issue than first thought. There is broad recognition around the need for reforms but local people and local councils need to influence the decisions, How this happens is a concern and accountability also. The second bill later this year will be clearer around pricing and how the entity will operate. This is just the beginning. I think councils are justified to ask a lot of questions about how these assests are taken care of. What would regional committees need to feed into? What would the process be , what level of development ,what level of detail? Statements of community outcomes - A High level aspirational document will need drafting for the council to input into What does Dunedin want, what do we include? And with increased climate change events water management it is a real problem.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Varied solutions – improvements to water catchments and harvesting, irrigation and agricultural practise. Education around consumption and conservation. Waste water recycling initiatives and holistic community based Co governance models Address pollution Measuring and monitoring water quality is essential to human health and biodiversity.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

4

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

A more reliable service, Covered bus stops with seating and cheaper fares will be my priorities . I will argue the case for DCC to take over this from ORC, and make sure Bus drivers are better paid

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Predator free Dunedin and the Halo project are great initiatives . I live in Waitati and we all support Rat traps and mustalid trapping in the area. We have almost removed Possums from around the Orokonui ecosanctuary and I am in support of these projects extending city wide

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

No

Rachel Elder (Independent)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Climate Change creating coastal erosion and large rain events.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

I have thought about this a lot - I would love it if the DCC/ORC/DOC could get together and map out the land that they own and together create a biodiversity plan and work together to achieve it. It could become a visionary project that could be put together to attract funding and create jobs.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

We should encourage the use of public transport, cycling , walking and mobility devises. We should also encourage electric cars - and buy electric for our own fleet. We should be educating in schools and in the community around reduce, reuse, recycle. I would love to see a webpage with for example all the 2nd hand clothing shops, furniture shops and who recycles say plastic plant pottles etc etc Have a tip a week on recycling Look into how we can reduce building waste as it is a big part of our waste stream and needs to dealt with Change our waste collection to 4 bins :Glass, Recyclables, Green Waste and general waste. Have a good sorting system at the landfill.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

We have a really beautiful city that is close to nature. My vision is a world class network of accessible walking/cycling trails that connect us to nature, adventures , communities and to regional cycle trails. I want to see these trails connecting us to our histories and culture ( both Tangata Whenua and Pakeha ) , to our harbours, inlets, beaches and basalt columns. I want these trails to enable us to trap predators effectively and also to do native tree planting. My vision would rely on people buying into it and sponsoring it. Many people are time poor and could donate $5.00, $10.00 per week and also there could be company sponsorships. My colleagues and I have created a Charitable Trust to make this happen. The Dunedin Tracks Network Trust and we have two feasibility studies being done - one to Waihola and the other to Wailouaiti. This vision is about the health and wellbeing of our people and our planet and combines the two. People will be attracted to Dunedin because it’s natural beauty and their ability to access it by foot or by bike. This is a tourism offering that will connect people with our natural beauty, wildlife and history in a healthy and low carbon way. Most of all it benefits the people of Dunedin as it enables them to have a healthy outdoors lifestyle that is connected to nature.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

We are 59 drivers short in Dunedin - we need bus drivers if we are to have a great public transport system and we also have to give them better conditions as they often work split shifts - which means long days. We need to pay our bus drivers more - and I have attended a protest to the Otago Regional Council about this. It is not acceptable to pay people who have worked years in the industry $22.75 hr. I do not believe giving them an extra 90c is going to attract more drivers to the industry!!

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

As a city councillor I believe we need good consultation and engagement with the community about big changes. There is a saying “ nothing about them without them “ . I believe there needs to be 3 waters reform for the health and wellbeing of our water and our infrastructure. It is also important we plan ahead for growth. I was very disappointed with Central Governments engagement and consultation with both Local Government and their communities. The 3 waters infrastructure is owned and managed byLocal Councils and local communities paid for them with their rates. This means there needed to be genuine consultation which enabled the opportunity to discuss a variety of models around ownership, governance , accountability, monitoring and financing options. Central Government through it’s process has confirmed people’s fears that local voices will not be heard by prescribing the model and then mandating it. I believe there needs to be a reset of the 3 waters reform to enable proper engagement and consultation to happen.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

I would like to see a set of monitoring sites and test them on a regular basis to understand what is happening and set a baseline. We do have bylaws around runoff and the community and business need to be educated around these and how we look after our streams, rivers and the sea. We need to hold people to account and fine people if necessary for non-compliance

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

I beleive we have to work together on this. To be honest if we are going to increase public transport we are going to have to attract more people to be bus drivers. They need to be paid a lot more. You can offer free buses, you can ask for more routes but without drivers you cannot achieve your public transport dreams.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

I believe we need to work together to sort this out.

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

I have thought about this a lot - I would love it if the DCC/ORC/DOC could get together and map out the land that they own and together create a biodiversity plan and work together to achieve it. It could become a visionary project that could be put together to attract funding and create jobs. 

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Cats are an apex predator so yes if we want to protect our biodiversity this conversation should be had.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes

Randal Scott

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Waste that is finding its way into an environment that should be pristine.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Ban freedom camping - Dunedin should look to cater for a smaller number of high spending tourists, reduce the number of visitors to Otago Peninsula, vastly improve recycling, and fund more pest control.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Reduce greenhouse gas emissions whenever and wherever we can. Push for the government to fund free public transport. Maintain infrastructure to a high standard to prepare for an uncertain future.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

I think free public transport is an idea whose time has come. The best thing we can do to reduce gridlock is to get cars off the road by providing free public transport, funded by the government.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

Push for more waste to be recycled, lobby government for free public transport, and look for local solutions to reduce, reuse and recycle.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

No. I think it’s asset theft. The government should set standards for three waters, not steal assets that have been paid for by generations of Dunedin ratepayers.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Demand action on eliminating E.coli from our city’s waterways. Ask the government to legislate for high water standards that will be enforced. Employ people to clean our city regularly.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Lobby for the government to provide free public transport. Match services to demand more effectively by using smaller buses on some routes. Ensure disability access.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

No

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Fund Predator Free Dunedin’s aim to achieve predator free status over 31,000 hectares in the city.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes, some pet owners in Dunedin have too many cats.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Richard Knights (Independent)

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

St Clair to St Kilda coastline and the impending issues of the old landfill at Kettle Park.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

I would work to prioritise funding and work for environmental initiatives such as native tree planting, dune protection/planting as well as reach out to the community in regards to what other measures are required to help and protect out natural environment. We need to work harder at protecting and nurturing our taonga species and keeping them from extinction and decline.

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

We are not responding fast enough to the climate crisis. Having declared a climate emergency, we need to do more to action positive change. We need to reduce our cities overall emissions and look to an integrated transport strategy that delivers tangible results in the fight against climate change. We need to engage with mana whenua and environmental experts to get some quick wins under our belt. We do not have the option of doing nothing!

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

The reliance on fossil fuelled transport needs to change and change quickly. Thankfully advances in technology mean that EV’s and electric buses are becoming viable alternatives. We need to embrace that change and technology and do more to encourage alternate methods of travel. My vision for the city is one where all road users are adequately catered for and public transport is efficient and available.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

I would actively support initiatives to drive us to our existing Carbon Zero 2030 goal. I would advocate for faster and greater change.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

Fundamentally yes. How can anyone be against clean drinking water and proper dealing with storm water and sewerage rather than it simply entering and polluting our waterways? What I am not on board with is the way that the initiatives are being delivered. More consideration needs to be given to the structure and the application to ensure that local authorities are still able to have an appropriate say in the 3 waters needs of their local communities. Local councils have a very important part to play in ensuring the needs of our local communities are not overlooked in this process and I will fight hard to ensure that they are!

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Investigate solutions and identify options for resolving issues where storm water is discharging directly into water bodies. Clean waterways are an absolute must for our city.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

I would certainly advocate for the transfer of public transport services to the Dunedin City Council in the first instance and closer and tighter working with the ORC if this can not be facilitated. Reliable, efficient and available public transport is the keystone to other mode shift and emission reduction goals. This building block needs to be in place, to allow the other work to take place!

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

Yes

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Look at ways in which more funding can be made available to complete this important work.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes. I support the registration of domestic cats, microchipping and desexing.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes. We have to protect our taonga species from extinction.

Sophie Barker (Independent)

Running for Mayor and Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Dunedin is the wildlife capital of NZ We need to action our environment strategy, Te Ao Turoa, has been neglected and the partnership dissolved by current council. This needs to be reactivated urgently.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Shake the dust off the environment strategy, re-form partnership. Write Climate Action Plan. Establish proper funding and resourcing for work. Dedicated team within Council More funds DCC biodiversity grants

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

Dunedin declared in 2010 it was going to write a Climate Action Plan. Council hasn’t delivered on positive action, despite declaring a climate emergency in 2019. We need to:

1. Write Climate Action Plan.
2. Work with partners to deliver.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

I want to make Dunedin the most liveable city in NZ. We are resilient, carbon zero, protect nature, live in harmony with environment. Commit to forms of transportation other than fossil fuels. eg plan a compact city that is easy to get around.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

1. Fast track the Climate Action Plan and action it.
2. Implement the Environment Strategy
3. Get public transport back from the ORC

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

I support safe drinking water for everyone, plus the aims of ensuring that we’re not degrading our environment through mismanagement of water assets. Water is life. But I’m also concerned with loss of local voice

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Refresh the Environment Strategy. Focus on delivering actions ie “Identify and protect areas of ecological significance, establish biodiversity and ecosystem health measures etc”

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Work with community to understand public transport wishes. Establish aims and objectives for what ‘Great bus services’ look like. Ensure funding for bus services included in DCC budget. Look at inner city loop bus. Sort out bus hub.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

UNDECIDED UNTIL WE LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

5

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Keep funding Predator Control. Work with community to shave vision and raise support for predator free work.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

I have three rescue cats, all chipped and well cared for. However I spent my childhood catching cats on Otago Peninsula and know what a very serious threat they are to wildlife.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

YES

Robyn McLean

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

Driving culture change on how we live, including waste management and recycling, pest management, reducing carbon emissions... It’s time for action across several areas, they are all interrelated and are all require action now.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

Environment is one of the 3 lenses that I will use across all discussions and decisions. I would continue to support progress towards a predator free Dunedin and drive a focus of true Waste minimisation and management throughout our city

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

6

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

In partnership with communities affected!! I am impressed with what the South Dunedin Future and Saint Clair/St Kilda Coastal plan have begun, this needs to continue and needs to become city wide focused, as well as looking after South D.

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

My long-term vision is to create well designed infrastructure that gives everyone options for commuting through the entire city. We need to create options to give people choice to move away from fossil fuelled transport asap.

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

I will hold the council to task in continuing the work they have begun in partnership with the ORC. I want to start seeing planning around solutions and the timing they might be required started with our communities.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

Yes I do, In principal I believe everyone in Aotearoa has a right to access clean drinking water and management of waste and storm water must be at a consistent level of quality across the country. I do not see this as ‘stealing assets’ and I support a model of co-governance.

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

Our rivers are so sick, I would take action to get more measures in place around water quality around the city and make sure these conversations happen at a council level so these results are actively monitored and root causes identified.

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

1

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

Advocate for buses to ultimately be controlled by Council, advocate that bus transport should be affordable, consistent, connecting both community hubs and CBD.

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

Yes

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

7

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Continue to support progress towards a predator free Dunedin, allowing more of our wonderful native bird populations to flourish.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

I do not have a cat because I love native birds. I believe this idea has merit; I currently don’t know enough about it. I would look more deeply into the solution and how it could be delivered in a way that respects both bird and cat lovers.

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

I do not love chemicals. However, to get serious on being pest free, areas where it is not practicable to do any other form of pest control, may need the use of 1080. I would not always support 1080 because it was most cost effective.

Steve Walker

Running for Dunedin City Council

What is the most pressing environmental issue in Dunedin?

There are multifarious issues facing Dunedin, from threats to our biodiversity to ridiculous accumulations of needless waste products, but of course the overriding area of concern has to be South Dunedin and our other vulnerable low lying communities given their precarious exposure to the effects of climate change.

If elected, what actions would you prioritise to protect and restore nature in Dunedin?

As Chair of the Dunedin Wildlife Hospital Trust Board I’ve had the privilege of seeing how we can take action to protect and restore some of our precious taonga species on a daily basis.

I also set up and Chair the West Harbour Beatification Trust which was responsible for removing thousands of invasive sycamore trees on Dunedin’s West Harbour. These have subsequently been replaced with thousands of (now thriving) native species.

I’m a strong advocate for protection and restoration of biodiversity and its natural environments and know many people working in this area. I will continue to advocate strongly for something I’m truly passionate about!

How would you rate Council's response to climate change in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

8

How should Dunedin City Council respond to the climate crisis?

The DCC has responded well to the climate crisis but MUSN’T take its foot off of the peddle.

2015 – DCC Resolution (The Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate & Energy) “urges the NZ Government to commit to a carbon emissions reduction target of 40% by 2030, relative to 1990 levels”.
2019 – DCC declares a Climate Emergency (including a city target of net zero carbon by 2030)
2019 – DCC approves establishing and commencing the delivery of a detailed work programme for climate mitigation and adaptation.
2022 – DCC approves the interim working principles for the Zero Carbon work programme.
2022 – DCC approves the revised Zero Carbon Alliance MOU and terms of reference.

Much still to do and I will be at the forefront of championing Dunedin in this space!

What is your long term vision for the city and to what extent does that vision rely on fossil fuels for personal transport?

Fossil fuels are already on the wane in terms of personal transport although even greater incentives to transition should always be considered in balance with making sure any transition is equitable and does not magnify existing socioeconomic inequalities! My five priorities for this election are self-explanatory in terms of the long term vision I have for Dunedin: 1. ZERO-CARBON by 2030 2. Protecting our unique BIODIVERSITY 3. MODE SHIFT – public transport, walking and cycling 4. Vibrant PEOPLE-FOCUSED city centres 5. Waste reduction – CIRCULAR ECONOMY

If elected, what specific actions will you take in response to the climate crisis?

I have moved many motions during the past triennium related to climate change action and I will continue to advocate strongly in this space. I will also continue to practice what I preach on climate matters – I cycle-commute around 6000kms per year, my wife and I produce only 1 (one) black bag of rubbish per year and as Chairperson of the Dunedin Wildlife Hospital Trust Board I’m ‘all in’ on advocating to protect our natural environment and our unique taonga species.

Freshwater

Do you support the Government's three waters initiative? Why or why not?

Partially. I’m certainly of the mind that the status quo is not an option and that all New Zealanders want clean, safe drinking water coming out of their taps and their wastewater removed in a way that doesn’t impinge on public health and the environment, these goals I support, along with a stronger voice for iwi-Māori in any potential new model. That said, many parts of the proposed Government’s model leave more questions than answers. In fact the current First Bill has questions that can’t be answered until a subsequent Bill is presented next year. My major concerns are around our Council’s obligations as a land planning authority and how this will be managed once the entity is established, loss of ‘local voices’ in decision making, transfer of asset questions and staffing issues. Much of this won’t be addressed until a later date so in essence we are currently being asked to make a decision akin to trying to complete a jigsaw puzzle with half the pieces missing!

Dunedin has its fair share of urban water issues, such as the Leith and Kaikorai having some of the highest levels of E.coli in the country and the storm water system for much of Dunedin draining directly into water bodies. How would you rate Council's effectiveness in managing drinking water, storm water and wastewater systems from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

3

If elected, what specific actions will you take to improve freshwater across the city?

I’d implore the ORC to do its job properly!

Public Transport

How would you rate public transport services in Dunedin from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

4

If elected, what specific actions would you take to improve public transport in Dunedin?

As you mention it’s an issue for the ORC. That said, I remain a strong advocate for the DCC taking over the bus network in Dunedin. If that ever eventuates we have to concentrate on, and invest in, making our core routes frequent, reliable and comfortable. All international evidence shows that this is a far better way of ensuring people shift to using PT rather than focusing on price incentives! 

Do you support some form of transfer of public transport services from Otago Regional Council to Dunedin City Council?

Yes

Do you support a switch from the one-way to two-way system?

This is difficult to answer in the absence of detailed evidence (other than vague unscientific polls!) of the merits of one over the other. This information is likely to come to us in the near future. That said, I will ALWAYS support the option that provides the best outcomes for city liveability (humans live in cities, not cars!), safety of pedestrians and cyclists and of course the option that best fulfils our obligations for a 2030 carbon-zero Dunedin.

Do you support making George Street more accessible for pedestrians?

Yes. I remain one of the few councillors advocating for full pedestrianisation of George Street, something I believe will still happen after people realise how wonderful the current George Street upgrade is!

Predator Control

How would you rate Council's predator control efforts from 1 (terrible) to 10 (excellent)?

9

If elected, what specific actions will you take to support predator control efforts in Dunedin?

Not only do I trap personally and have done so for eons, I have fully supported the work of PFD, the Halo Project, City Sanctuary and the Otago Peninsula Biodiversity Group – They all do incredible mahi. I obviously have a vested interest in predator control in my capacity as Dunedin Wildlife Hospital Trust Chair, so will continue to advocate for all efforts in this space.

If elected, would you support continued funding for Predator Free Dunedin?

Yes

Forest & Bird Dunedin has previously advocated for Council to explore opportunities for improved cat control. If elected, would you be supportive of this?

Yes, and I have in fact been doing some initial research around how to best progress this – watch this space!

Do you support the use of 1080 to control invasive predators in areas where other methods are not practicable, or where this is the most cost-effective method?

Yes, but only in large-scale, remote and difficult terrain. The whio success would likely have not been possible without DOC using 1080. It’s an unfortunate quandary, but much of our precious and endangered birdlife is dependent, at this point, on 1080 for their survival.